Cap rate vs cash-on-cash return
Both numbers describe the same rental. One ignores your loan entirely; the other is built almost entirely around it. Confusing them is the most common reason two investors look at one property and walk away with opposite conclusions.
The two formulas
Cap rate = NOI ÷ Purchase priceCash-on-cash = Annual cash flow ÷ Cash investedCap rate is unlevered: no mortgage anywhere in the calculation. Cash-on-cash is levered: it exists only because you borrowed money.
Same deal, two different numbers
Take the duplex from the DSCR guide — $300,000, 25% down, NOI of $20,442, cash flow of $2,930, and $81,000 of cash in the deal after closing costs:
| Metric | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Cap rate | $20,442 ÷ $300,000 | 6.81% |
| Cash-on-cash | $2,930 ÷ $81,000 | 3.62% |
Same building. One number is nearly double the other. Neither is wrong — they are answering different questions.
- Cap rate: "What does this property yield if I paid all cash?"
- Cash-on-cash: "What does my actual money earn this year, after the mortgage?"
When leverage helps, and when it hurts
Debt is a multiplier on the spread between cap rate and your interest rate.
If cap rate > loan rate → leverage helps cash-on-cashIn the example the cap rate is 6.81% and the loan costs 6.75%. The spread is almost nothing, which is why cash-on-cash (3.62%) sits well below cap rate — you are paying nearly as much for the money as the property yields, before expenses on the borrowed portion.
This is also why a deal can look great on cap rate and mediocre on cash-on-cash. That is not a contradiction. It is the cost of borrowing a large share of the purchase price.
The case where cap rate flatters the deal
Here is a $250,000 single-family rental, 20% down at 7.25%, renting for $2,000 a month:
| Net operating income | $13,322 |
| Cap rate | 5.33% |
| Annual debt service | $16,372 |
| Cash flow | −$3,050 |
| Cash-on-cash | −5.55% |
| DSCR | 0.81 |
A 5.33% cap rate sounds like a normal, unexciting property. But this one loses $3,050 a year at the closing table, because the mortgage costs more than the property produces. Cap rate never sees that; cash-on-cash is nothing else.
The case where cash-on-cash flatters the deal
Now reverse it. An owner-occupied fourplex where you live in one unit and rent the other three can show a healthy cash-on-cash, because part of the "return" is rent you no longer pay yourself. That is a real benefit — but it is not a return on the property. It is a return on your housing decision.
The same distortion appears with interest-only loans: the payment is smaller, cash flow looks better, and the principal is not going anywhere.
Which one should you use?
| Situation | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Comparing properties in a market | Cap rate | Removes financing differences between deals |
| Deciding whether you should buy this one | Cash-on-cash | It reflects the loan you will actually sign |
| Taking to a lender | DSCR | It is the number their credit policy is written around |
| Comparing against a savings account | Cash-on-cash, then IRR | Cash-on-cash ignores appreciation and principal paydown |
What both of them leave out
Neither metric accounts for three things that decide how a rental actually performs over time:
- Principal paydown. Part of every payment becomes equity. Neither cap rate nor cash-on-cash sees it.
- Appreciation. Ignored by both. This is usually why people accept low cash-on-cash in the first place.
- Exit costs. Selling costs and taxes land at the end, and they are large enough to change the ranking of two deals.
That is what IRR is for, and it is why a deal with 3.6% cash-on-cash can still be a 11.8% IRR over five years. The calculator reports all of them side by side so you can see where the return is actually coming from.
See both numbers for your deal. Enter the purchase price, loan terms and rent — the calculator returns cap rate, cash-on-cash, DSCR and IRR from the same assumptions.
Open the calculator