How much can you actually pull out of a BRRRR refinance?
BRRRR gets sold as a way to buy rentals with none of your own money left in the deal. Sometimes it works. Often the refinance returns less than the renovation cost — and the arithmetic that tells you which is a five-line calculation you can do before you buy.
The formula
Cash out = (After-repair value × LTV) − existing loan balance − refinance costsEvery term matters, and two of them are outside your control at the moment you need them most: the appraisal and the lender's LTV.
A worked example where the refinance returns nothing
Buy a duplex for $120,000, put $35,000 of work into it, rent both units for $2,800 a month combined. Initial loan of $90,000 at 75% LTV, interest-only for the first year.
| Purchase price | $120,000 |
| Renovation | $35,000 |
| Down payment | $30,000 |
| Closing costs, 2% | $2,400 |
| Total cash invested | $67,400 |
Two years later the property appraises at exactly what you paid — $120,000. The renovation improved the building but the market did not reward it at appraisal time, which happens more often than the case studies suggest.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| New loan, 75% of $120,000 | $90,000 |
| Pay off existing loan | −$90,000 |
| Refinance costs, 2% | −$1,800 |
| Cash out | −$1,800 |
You paid $1,800 for the privilege of replacing one loan with an identical one. All $67,400 stays in the deal.
What the value has to be
Same deal, different appraisals:
| After-repair value | New loan (75%) | Cash out after payoff and costs |
|---|---|---|
| $120,000 | $90,000 | −$1,800 |
| $150,000 | $112,500 | $20,250 |
| $180,000 | $135,000 | $42,300 |
| $217,000 | $162,750 | $69,495 |
To get the full $67,400 back you need an appraisal around $217,000 — nearly $62,000 more than the purchase price plus renovation. That is the number to check before you believe a BRRRR story.
The arithmetic behind it:
Required ARV = (loan balance + refinance costs + cash you want back) ÷ LTVWith a 75% LTV, every dollar you want out requires about $1.33 of value. That leverage works for you on the way up and against you when the appraisal disappoints.
The three things that actually decide it
1. How much value the renovation creates. Not how much it costs — how much the market pays for it. A $35,000 kitchen in a $90,000 house usually does not appraise at $35,000 more.
2. The lender's LTV. 70% versus 75% is not a rounding difference. On the $150,000 appraisal above, 70% LTV pulls out $15,000 instead of $20,250.
3. Your all-in basis. Purchase plus renovation plus closing costs plus holding costs. The lower that number, the less value you need to create.
What happens when the cash does not come back
The deal is not automatically dead — it is a different deal. You now have $67,400 permanently invested in a property that cash flows. Whether that is acceptable depends on the return on that capital, which is what IRR measures.
Two numbers to look at before deciding:
- Cash-on-cash on the money actually left in the deal, not on the money you hoped to recycle.
- IRR over the hold, including the sale. A property that returns capital slowly at 9% IRR is a mediocre investment; the same property at 16% is worth keeping.
The mistake that makes BRRRR look easy
Assuming the refinance appraises at purchase price plus renovation cost. Appraisals are based on comparable sales, not on what you spent. If the neighborhood's comps support $150,000, that is the number — regardless of the $35,000 you put in.
Run the deal at the appraisal you would be disappointed by, not the one you hope for. If it still works, the upside is a bonus rather than a requirement.
Test the refinance before you commit. The calculator models an interest-only period, a mid-hold refinance, and the cash-out it produces — alongside IRR and the sale at the end of the hold.
Open the calculatorRelated
- How to calculate DSCR — the refinance lender will test this too
- When negative cash flow is still a reasonable bet